Preventive and Mitigative Safeguards: How They Help Prevent Process Safety Incidents

Introduction

Layers of Protection Analysis (LOPA) is one of the most used risk management tools by the chemical processing industry in the USA. Companies utilize safeguards for various events or hazards that may unexpectedly happen and cause the worst possible outcome. LOPA safety helps identify the frequency of those events to prevent harmful outcomes. This plays an important role in the safety of the chemical process, as it can help identify and study Independent Protection Layers (IPLs) to prevent hazardous scenarios.

LOPA helps create cost-effective safety solutions by providing a more comprehensive grasp of risks than qualitative assessments in the early stages of project development. Additionally, LOPA safety promotes establishing a strong safety culture in organizations, leading to a substantial decrease in the probability of adverse incidents and ensuring the safeguarding of personnel, facilities, and communities in proximity.

What Are Safeguards? 

A safeguard is a design feature, equipment, procedure, or software crucial in hazardous industries, particularly chemical processing plants. It is used to prevent incidents or minimize the impact of an event. This measure is important to protect the lives of operators and personnel, the environment, the workplace, and the property. Here are some common safeguards used in industries:

  • Basic Process Control Systems – These are the primary control systems that manage normal chemical process operations. This will maintain the optimal operating conditions and help prevent inconsistency that could cause hazardous events.
  • Safety Instrumented Systems – These include the hardware and software that implement Safety Instrumented Functions, providing a systematic approach to safety. SIS will enhance overall safety by ensuring critical safety actions are taken even if the primary control system fails.
  • Alarm Systems – These signal operators of any abnormal conditions in the process. They help ensure operators can quickly identify potential issues before they lead to serious incidents, increasing situational awareness.
  • Active Fire Protection – This includes foam, sprinklers, spray, and flood systems that quickly extinguish fires. It will minimize damage to equipment and prevent the spread of fire to other areas of the facility
  • Emergency Response – This encompasses both on-site and off-site emergency response plans and teams prepared to act in case of an incident. Response teams can immediately address emergencies, coordinate evacuations, and manage the situation to reduce the chance of injury and damage.

Two Types of Safeguards 

In chemical processing plants, safety management relies on two types of safeguards: preventive and mitigative. Each serves distinct functions and operates at different phases of incident management. Understanding their differences and connections is essential for effective risk mitigation.

Preventive and mitigative safeguards represent different yet complementary approaches to process safety. Preventive safeguards are proactive measures designed to identify and control hazards to avoid unexpected incidents. They form the beginning line of defense and intend to eliminate or minimize the frequency of hazardous events. On the other hand, mitigative safeguards are reactive measures performed to minimize the consequences of an incident that has already occurred.

While preventive and mitigative safeguards have distinct roles, they support each other. A strong process safety management system requires a balanced combination of both. Preventive measures reduce the probability of incidents but cannot eliminate all risks. Furthermore, mitigative safeguards manage residual risks and minimize potential consequences. These safeguards focus on containing damage, protecting personnel, and restoring operations.

Safeguards and IPL: What’s the Difference? 

IPLs are specialized safeguards designed to prevent or minimize hazardous events independently. Unlike standard safeguards, IPLs are unaffected by other safety systems or the initiating events as they operate on their own. They are important components of a powerful process safety management system, providing multiple independent layers of protection against potential incidents. To qualify as an independent layer of protection, a safeguard must meet specific criteria, including independence, specificity, and reliability.

IPLs are critical in enhancing process safety. By including IPLs in process designs, organizations can reduce the frequency and consequences of hazardous events. The effectiveness of IPLs is measured through quantitative standards such as risk reduction factors and probability of failure on demand, enabling data-driven decision-making.

How Does a Safeguard Become an IPL? 

Safeguards must qualify for specific criteria to become IPLs. These seven core criteria are Independence, Functionality, Reliability, Integrity, Auditability, Access Security, and Management of Change. 

  • Independence – IPL functions are unaffected by initiating events or failures of other safeguards. Common cause failures compromising IPL independence must be considered.
  • Functionality – IPL fully prevents or mitigates consequences, operating as expected under hazardous conditions and responding effectively within the required timeframe, even if other protection layers fail.
  • Reliability – Probability IPL operates as intended under stated conditions for a specified duration.
  • Integrity – IPL’s dependability in completely preventing scenario consequences is based on reasonably achievable risk reduction given design and management.
  • Auditability – IPLs are periodically validated to confirm that they effectively prevent consequences as designed, with appropriate installation, testing, and maintenance systems in place.
  • Access Security – Administrative controls and physical means are used to reduce the probability of unintentional or unauthorized safeguard changes.
  • Management of Change – Formal process to review, document, and approve safeguard modifications before implementation.

Seven Core Attributes of Independent Protection Layer (IPLs)

Conclusion

Layers of protection analysis is a vital risk management technique in the chemical processing industry in the USA. It identifies hazards and assesses existing safeguards. Preventive safeguards, such as basic process control and alarm systems, proactively reduce incident frequency. In contrast, mitigative safeguards, including active fire protection and emergency response plans, minimize the impact of incidents that occur.

Independent layers of protection offer multiple defense layers against hazards. A balanced combination of these safeguards fosters a strong safety culture, lowers the likelihood of adverse incidents, and protects personnel, facilities, and surrounding communities.

Learn more about layers of protection analysis in the USA with help from Saltegra Consulting LLC. Contact our consulting firm today!

Authors